homes for sale in
fish creek / gibraltar
fish creek / gibraltar
The bayside village of Fish Creek is a lively, walkable town that includes some of Door County’s best known shops and restaurants, and borders Peninsula State Park. The town is also home to theaters, galleries and Door County’s largest performance venue, the Door Community Auditorium. Gibraltar Schools sit atop the Fish Creek hill, one of two public school systems that serve the children of Northern Door County.
- Peninsula State Park is widely known as the Jewel of the Peninsula.
- Find Fish Creek events, businesses and more information here.
- The Door Community Auditorium features year round concerts, lectures and arts events.
- Peninsula Players is America’s oldest resident summer theater, and its beautiful lakeside setting offers an unforgettable night out.
- Peninsula School of Art offers year-round workshops, lectures, exhibits and family-friendly events for students of all ages and abilities.
available listings
County Rd F
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
25Picture(s)
25.52Acre
Visits:857
Enjoy a panorama of scenic Gibraltar farm fields and countryside from this uniquely situated, gently sloping acreage just a few miles from Fish Creek, Ephraim and Baileys Harbor. 20 of the 25.5 acres is currently use value assessed for agriculture. Access to the acreage, situated over 700 feet from Cty. F, is via an unimproved driveway and utility easement.
$419,900Sold for 419,900.00 on 12/10/24
9270 County Rd A
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
PavedParking(s)
43Picture(s)
1,472
Visits:1391
This charming cottage in the woods can be your perfect vacation getaway or cozy year-round home. The well maintained ranch features open-concept first-floor living plus a large finished family room or over-flow sleeping area in the basement. The 3-car garage includes one insulated stall with gas heater perfect for a studio, workshop, or office.
$499,000Sold for 450,000.00 on 01/13/25
9059 Spring Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
Kellstrom-Ray Agency
2Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
PavedParking(s)
75Picture(s)
2,441
Visits:323
Location, location, location! This custom built, 2 bedroom home offers 9' ceilings, hardwood floors, granite countertops, gas fireplace in the living room, 1st floor primary suite, sunroom, 2nd floor bonus room plus den, attached & heated 2 car garage & more. There is a separate carriage house with one car garage & additional living space above, perfect for a home office along with a half bath.
$879,900Sold for 860,000.00 on 04/18/25
9265 Half Mile Bridge Dr
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
2Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
Assigned ParkingParking(s)
14Picture(s)
1,494
Visits:645
Walk straight to downtown Fish Creek on the paved pedestrian path from this perfectly situated, private unit at Half Mile Bridge. Two bedrooms, both with ensuite baths, make this a great unit for entertaining and overnight guests. New water heater 2023, new refrigerator 2018, new furnace 2021. This unit features the optional sunroom with vaulted ceiling and added entertaining space.
$399,000Sold for 412,500.00 on 09/27/24
TBD County Rd F
Fish Creek, 54212
Shorewest Realtors-Door County
12Picture(s)
5.47Acre
Visits:377
This centrally located vacant land offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and practical benefits. A portion of the 5.47 acres is actively farmed, which helps reduce property taxes, making it an attractive investment. The land also features a picturesque wooded area, providing privacy and a serene environment.
$169,900
3757 S Northhaven Dr
Fish Creek, 54212
Shorewest Realtors-Door County
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
1 Car GarageParking(s)
39Picture(s)
2,115
Visits:349
Explore this newly updated 3-bedroom unit at Northhaven! This spacious upper-level home offers a split bedroom layout for greater privacy, making it perfect as a primary residence or a getaway retreat. The open kitchen, dining, and living areas extend to a deck with picturesque meadow views. The master suite is thoughtfully separated from the secondary bedrooms and bathroom for added tranquility.
$550,000Sold for 575,000.00 on 09/26/24
lot 3& 4 County Rd EE
Town Of Gibraltar, 54212
Kellstrom-Ray Agency
9Picture(s)
10.40Acre
Visits:404
Ten acres centrally located between northern Door and Sturgeon Bay. Mostly open and rolling. Great site to build and raise a family with room to roam or room for a home and a building to store your toys, so many options and possibilities! Located just a couple of miles to Baileys Harbor with great food options, public waters, shops and more! Call for details.
$249,900Sold for 240,000.00 on 03/31/25
3906 County Rd F
Fish Creek, 54212
CB Real Estate Group Egg Harbor
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
No GarageParking(s)
22Picture(s)
896
Visits:352
Location, location, location! Fantastic opportunity to own an affordable 2 bedroom townhouse within walking distance to shops, restaurants, YMCA, Peninsula State Park, and the Door County Auditorium. Live here year round, use it as a second home, or rent it when you are not using it (1 week rental minimum) On-site outdoor pool, whirlpool, and laundry facilities.
$270,000Sold for 280,000.00 on 08/27/24
4240 Juddville Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
2Bathroom(s)
11-25 spacesParking(s)
36Picture(s)
2,396
Visits:2624
This attractive commercial property is situated on 1.17 acres in the heart of Juddville, ensuring maximum exposure and accessibility. This offering features a large commercial kitchen, a charming bar, two spacious dining/multi-use areas, a wrap-around porch, ample parking, and a separate retail shop.
$550,000
4112 Choke Cherry Ln Unit 1902
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
2 Car GarageParking(s)
6Picture(s)
1,704
Visits:482
Welcome to Redtail Ridge, Fish Creek's newest residential condominium! Ideally located just south of downtown Fish Creek, Redtail Ridge offers 2 bedroom and 3 bedroom floorplans. Designed for easy living with open concept living/kitchen, first floor laundry hook-ups, large windows and 9' ceilings. Personalize with your interior finishing selections.
$479,900Sold for 479,900.00 on 05/02/25
4112 Choke Cherry Ln Unit 1901
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
2 Car GarageParking(s)
6Picture(s)
1,704
Visits:409
PLAN D. Welcome to Redtail Ridge, Fish Creek's newest residential condominium! Ideally located just south of downtown Fish Creek, Redtail Ridge offers four floorplans ranging in size from 790 sq ft - 1,704 sq ft. Designed for easy living with open concept living/kitchen, first floor laundry hook-ups, large windows and 9' ceilings.
$479,900Sold for 479,900.00 on 02/03/25
4120 Choke Cherry Ln Unit 2902
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
OtherParking(s)
6Picture(s)
1,050
Visits:380
NEW CONSTRUCTION/PLAN B. Welcome to Redtail Ridge, Fish Creek's newest residential condominium! Ideally located just south of downtown Fish Creek, Redtail Ridge offers four floorplans ranging in size from 790 sq ft - 1,704 sq ft. Designed for easy living with open concept living/kitchen, first floor laundry hook-ups, large windows and 9' ceilings.
$339,900Sold for 374,900.00 on 03/20/25