homes for sale in
fish creek / gibraltar
fish creek / gibraltar
The bayside village of Fish Creek is a lively, walkable town that includes some of Door County’s best known shops and restaurants, and borders Peninsula State Park. The town is also home to theaters, galleries and Door County’s largest performance venue, the Door Community Auditorium. Gibraltar Schools sit atop the Fish Creek hill, one of two public school systems that serve the children of Northern Door County.
- Peninsula State Park is widely known as the Jewel of the Peninsula.
- Find Fish Creek events, businesses and more information here.
- The Door Community Auditorium features year round concerts, lectures and arts events.
- Peninsula Players is America’s oldest resident summer theater, and its beautiful lakeside setting offers an unforgettable night out.
- Peninsula School of Art offers year-round workshops, lectures, exhibits and family-friendly events for students of all ages and abilities.
available listings
Peninsula Players Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
23Picture(s)
1.40Acre
Visits:1706
A rare and remarkable opportunity awaits with this approx 200-foot shorefront lot in the Town of Gibraltar—an ideal setting to build your dream home in the heart of Door County. Nestled between the charming village of Egg Harbor and Fish Creek, this wooded property offers both privacy and convenience.
$1,235,000Sold for 1,017,500.00 on 09/04/25
4240 Juddville Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
No GarageParking(s)
31Picture(s)
2,356Sqft
Visits:421
Here's an opportunity to transform an attractive commercial property into your dream Door County retreat. Situated on 1.17 acres in the heart of the County, the house features a large kitchen, a charming bar and seating areas, two spacious multi-use rooms, a sizeable wrap-around porch, and beautiful hardwood floors. The spacious main floor room can easily be transformed into two bedrooms.
$499,000
4054 Main St
Fish Creek, 54212
Mahler Sotheby's International Realty
2Bathroom(s)
PavedParking(s)
39Picture(s)
1,764Sqft
Visits:440
Incredible business and real estate opportunity- a rare chance to own both a thriving business and prime real estate in the heart of Fish Creek! Established in 1982, this beloved destination manufactures and retails homemade frozen custard- often hailed as the best in the Midwest.
$3,000,000
8925-2 Hedeen Way
Fish Creek, 54212
CB Real Estate Group Egg Harbor
3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
1 Car GarageParking(s)
41Picture(s)
3,000Sqft
Visits:319
Beautiful, oversized townhome at Hedemora Hills at Little Sweden—fully furnished and ready for your enjoyment! Perfect for a combination of personal use and renting, this spacious, light-filled home features a soaring two-story great room with a dramatic Door County fieldstone fireplace, oversized bedrooms, and a finished walk-out lower level with den, bath, and a beautiful custom bar--ideal for
$649,900
3170 Gibraltar Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
Kellstrom-Ray Agency
3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
OtherParking(s)
52Picture(s)
1,680Sqft
Visits:329
Enjoy this summer & all seasons in this wonderful Gibraltar Road home. The living room has a beamed wood ceiling and corner fireplace. Many upgrades have been done including a first-floor primary bedroom suite in 2022, new dining room, kitchen, laundry and bathroom upgrades, floorcoverings, and windows. This sparkling home is ready for you to move in and start enjoying. Tons of closet space.
$699,000Sold for 710,000.00 on 06/30/25
3908 County Rd F
Fish Creek, 54212
Shorewest Realtors
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
No GarageParking(s)
52Picture(s)
802Sqft
Visits:370
-Welcome to Hollywood Townhouse at Hilltop- Situated directly across from the DC Auditorium Venue, home to Hollywood stars like Johnny Cash, the Beach Boys, and the Indigo Girls, this charming 2-bedroom, 2-bath townhouse is just a stone's throw from , shopping, dining, and a delightful stroll downtown to the beach. Enjoy this harbored town on the Bay of Green Bay.
$279,900Sold for 275,000.00 on 07/02/25
Gibraltar Bluff Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
8Picture(s)
10Acre
Visits:1496
[This sale was for the 5-acre south lot plus the 2/5 interest in the 30' strip of land to the south.] This may truly be a once in a lifetime opportunity: ten acres of mature deciduous and coniferous trees with about 450 feet of bluff frontage just south of Fish Creek. This property offers stunning views of Green Bay and exceptional privacy unmatched in today's market.
$2,950,000Sold for 1,595,000.00 on 07/21/25
8391 Island View Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
Sarkis & Associates
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
PavedParking(s)
56Picture(s)
1,966Sqft
Visits:469
One of the best views in all Door County! Quintessential Door County Cottage overlooking the Bay of Green Bay just minutes from Fish Creek. Marvel at the two story wood burning fireplace while enjoying beautiful sunsets. Enjoy a book in the cozy library with a fireplace of its own. Detached garage has bonus space above with a wood burning stove.
$849,900Sold for 730,000.00 on 09/23/25
Hwy 42
Fish Creek, 54212
Harbour Real Estate Group LLC
4Picture(s)
1.37Acre
Visits:400
A beautiful deep lot with plenty of evergreens and hardwoods. A perfect home site for anyone who wants to be between Fish Creek and Egg Harbor.
$139,000Sold for 139,900.00 on 05/31/25
3868 County Rd F
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
PavedParking(s)
29Picture(s)
2,128Sqft
Visits:320
Delighfully updated single level home within walking distance to Fish Creek shops and restaurants, YMCA, Peninsula School of Art, and Door Community Auditorium. Open concept living space with a separate den for quiet enjoyment. Living room features vaulted ceilings, skylights, and fieldstone wood burning fireplace. Flagstone walkways, covered patio, and low maintenance private backyard.
$849,900Sold for 835,000.00 on 06/02/25
4071 Welcker Cliff Dr
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
3Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
PavedParking(s)
59Picture(s)
4,291Sqft
Visits:1085
Experience luxury and innovation in this nearly new custom 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath home, thoughtfully designed with elegant finishes and main-level living. Enjoy a gourmet kitchen w/ high-end appliances, hardwood floors, crown molding, & a luxe primary suite with steam shower. A cozy library w/ window seat offers a peaceful retreat, while the office/den doubles as a 4th bedroom.
$1,395,000Sold for 1,415,000.00 on 06/19/25
TBD Gibraltar Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
CB Real Estate Group Fish Creek
4Picture(s)
12Acre
Visits:315
Rare offering! 12 wooded acres near Fish Creek and Ephraim. Several amazing homesites for you to build your dream home on. Moderate deed restrictions to insure your investment.
$305,000Sold for 305,000.00 on 07/09/25