homes for sale in
fish creek / gibraltar
fish creek / gibraltar
The bayside village of Fish Creek is a lively, walkable town that includes some of Door County’s best known shops and restaurants, and borders Peninsula State Park. The town is also home to theaters, galleries and Door County’s largest performance venue, the Door Community Auditorium. Gibraltar Schools sit atop the Fish Creek hill, one of two public school systems that serve the children of Northern Door County.
- Peninsula State Park is widely known as the Jewel of the Peninsula.
- Find Fish Creek events, businesses and more information here.
- The Door Community Auditorium features year round concerts, lectures and arts events.
- Peninsula Players is America’s oldest resident summer theater, and its beautiful lakeside setting offers an unforgettable night out.
- Peninsula School of Art offers year-round workshops, lectures, exhibits and family-friendly events for students of all ages and abilities.
available listings
Tanglewood Ln
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
9Picture(s)
3.52Acre
Visits:1136
You can get anywhere from here! Perfectly located in the middle of Northern Door County, close to Northern Sky Theater and the Greenwood Supper Club, and less than ten minutes to Fish Creek, Egg Harbor, and Baileys Harbor. This 3.5 acre, nicely wooded lot is ready for your dream home. Attractive hardwoods and nice surrounding homes. Electric along Tanglewood Lane (a private road).
$149,900Sold for 135,000.00 on 08/26/25
Lot 20 Daisy Patch Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
Harbour Real Estate Group LLC
8Picture(s)
1.30Acre
Visits:375
Build your house on a bluff with a westerly sunset view overlooking Green Bay. This lot is perched above a Land Trust property so your view of Chambers Island, Hat Island and the lights of Marinette/Menominee will never be blocked. The property is located between Fish Creek and Egg Harbor. The driveway has been put in and the septic area prepped. The driveway was widened in 2025.
$299,999
9423 Spruce St
Fish Creek, 54212
Arbor Crowne Properties
2Bathroom(s)
On StreetParking(s)
21Picture(s)
3,663Sqft
Visits:449
A perfect location in quintessential Fish Creek. Rare, one-of-a-kind historic property in the center of this notable town . Beautifully renovated in 2016, including new mechanicals, this prestigious building shows hardwood floors, sun filled rooms, full length windows & two large stone fireplaces.
$2,150,000Sold for 1,812,500.00 on 08/20/25
Lot 5 White Cliff Woods Ln
Fish Creek, 54212
CB Real Estate Group Egg Harbor
16Picture(s)
1.74Acre
Visits:357
First time to the market! The 6 parcels within this small land division sold privately years ago and this is the first opportunity for one to be available for sale! This little lane is perfectly situated off W Juddville Road and is centrally located for an easy drive to Egg Harbor and Fish Creek The lot is fairly flat and features mostly deciduous trees.
$145,000
9632 County Rd A
Fish Creek, 54212
Shorewest Realtors-Door County
4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
DetachedParking(s)
35Picture(s)
2,055Sqft
Visits:431
Nestled on an acre of natural beauty, this property offers timeless character with thoughtful modern updates. Built in 1940, and renovated in 2020s, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home features a classic design enhanced by vaulted ceilings, skylights, and exposed log.
$599,900Sold for 575,000.00 on 11/03/25
8282 White Cliff Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
Dwell Door County
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
DetachedParking(s)
65Picture(s)
1,855Sqft
Visits:434
Style and functionality combine to create a beautiful year-round home or vacation getaway. This thoughtfully-designed, manicured property must be seen to be appreciated. Tucked away in the woods; a short path through the front yard will bring you to little-known public water access directly across the street.
$899,900Sold for 899,900.00 on 07/30/25
TBD S Highland Rd
Town Of Gibraltar, 54212
Kellstrom-Ray Agency
13Picture(s)
3.52Acre
Visits:381
This beautifully wooded 3.2 acre corner lot offers the peace and privacy you've been searching for. Nestled along scenic South Highland Road in the town of Gibraltar, the property provides an ideal setting for your dream home or vacation retreat.
$135,000Sold for 135,000.00 on 10/10/25
TBD Gibraltar Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
Sunnypoint Real Estate LLC
10Picture(s)
10.02Acre
Visits:384
Choose from several homesites to build your dream home on this beautiful, fully wooded 10 acre parcel. Centrally located in the heart of the peninsula, off the beaten path yet just minutes from Fish Creek, Ephraim, Baileys Harbor & Egg Harbor. Moderate protective covenants in place to ensure your investment.
$298,000Sold for 278,000.00 on 08/30/25
Peninsula Players Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
23Picture(s)
1.40Acre
Visits:1990
A rare and remarkable opportunity awaits with this approx 200-foot shorefront lot in the Town of Gibraltar—an ideal setting to build your dream home in the heart of Door County. Nestled between the charming village of Egg Harbor and Fish Creek, this wooded property offers both privacy and convenience.
$1,235,000Sold for 1,017,500.00 on 09/04/25
4240 Juddville Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
No GarageParking(s)
31Picture(s)
2,356Sqft
Visits:757
Here's an opportunity to transform an attractive commercial property into your dream Door County retreat. Situated on 1.17 acres in the heart of the County, the house features a large kitchen, a charming bar and seating areas, two spacious multi-use rooms, a sizeable wrap-around porch, and beautiful hardwood floors. The spacious main floor room can easily be transformed into two bedrooms.
$499,000
4054 Main St
Fish Creek, 54212
Mahler Sotheby's International Realty
2Bathroom(s)
PavedParking(s)
39Picture(s)
1,764Sqft
Visits:779
Incredible business and real estate opportunity- a rare chance to own both a thriving business and prime real estate in the heart of Fish Creek! Established in 1982, this beloved destination manufactures and retails homemade frozen custard- often hailed as the best in the Midwest.
$2,700,000
8925-2 Hedeen Way
Fish Creek, 54212
CB Real Estate Group Egg Harbor
3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
GarageParking(s)
41Picture(s)
3,000Sqft
Visits:573
Beautiful, oversized townhome at Hedemora Hills at Little Sweden—fully furnished and ready for your enjoyment! Perfect for a combination of personal use and renting, this spacious, light-filled home features a soaring two-story great room with a dramatic Door County fieldstone fireplace, oversized bedrooms, and a finished walk-out lower level with den, bath, and a beautiful custom bar--ideal for
$649,900Sold for 625,000.00 on 01/31/26