homes for sale in
fish creek / gibraltar
fish creek / gibraltar
The bayside village of Fish Creek is a lively, walkable town that includes some of Door County’s best known shops and restaurants, and borders Peninsula State Park. The town is also home to theaters, galleries and Door County’s largest performance venue, the Door Community Auditorium. Gibraltar Schools sit atop the Fish Creek hill, one of two public school systems that serve the children of Northern Door County.
- Peninsula State Park is widely known as the Jewel of the Peninsula.
- Find Fish Creek events, businesses and more information here.
- The Door Community Auditorium features year round concerts, lectures and arts events.
- Peninsula Players is America’s oldest resident summer theater, and its beautiful lakeside setting offers an unforgettable night out.
- Peninsula School of Art offers year-round workshops, lectures, exhibits and family-friendly events for students of all ages and abilities.
available listings
3865 County Rd F
Fish Creek, 54212
Kellstrom-Ray Agency
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
No GarageParking(s)
41Picture(s)
1,619Sqft
Visits:310
Charming Cape Cod home in a great Fish Creek location.! You are walking distance to Gibraltar School & Auditorium, Art School, YMCA, shopping & dining & Peninsula State Park. The home sits back from the road, offers lots of privacy and a big backyard. Large bedrooms, great light and some hardwood floors. This year-round home has been used as a STR. Full basement, municipal sewer.
$499,900Sold for 500,000.00 on 01/07/26
9448 Maple Grove Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
Professional Realty of Door County
16Picture(s)
6.01Acre
Visits:344
Beautiful sloping lot of 6 acres, with a nice mixture of maple, birch and pine trees. Located on Maple Grove Road, with expansive views towards Ephraim. Conveniently located between Ephraim and Fish Creek, which makes this an ideal spot - out in the country, yet close to town.
$349,000Sold for 349,000.00 on 01/02/26
4160 Bluff Cr
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
5Bedroom(s)
5Bathroom(s)
AttachedParking(s)
1Picture(s)
4,808Sqft
Visits:746
Spectacular views of the Fish Creek harbor, Green Bay waters, and Peninsula State Park highlight this 4,800 square foot, recently updated custom home. Designed for entertaining, it features a spacious great room with fireplace, open to modern well-appointed kitchen. The expansive deck is ideal for large gatherings or a quiet relaxing evening enjoying the amazing views.
$2,095,000Sold for 2,095,000.00 on 11/24/25
4224 Hidden Harbor Ln
Fish Creek, 54212
Arbor Crowne Properties
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
NoneParking(s)
32Picture(s)
1,500Sqft
Visits:397
Tucked away, just off Main Street, in the heart of Fish Creek, Hidden Harbor offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and convenience. This exceptional first floor end unit features an open floor plan anchored by a stunning fieldstone fireplace and a four seasons porch. First floor primary ensuite with two generous guest rooms.
$947,000Sold for 1,035,000.00 on 12/20/25
9275 Spring Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
5Bedroom(s)
5Bathroom(s)
AttachedParking(s)
52Picture(s)
3,437Sqft
Visits:746
Ideally located within easy walking distance of Fish Creek, this thoughtfully designed, custom-built, and well-maintained home has to be seen to be appreciated. You will love the layout: first floor main bedroom with updated bathroom, spacious living areas, an open concept kitchen and dining room.
$995,000Sold for 970,000.00 on 11/17/25
8519 Hwy 42
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
DetachedParking(s)
68Picture(s)
3,368Sqft
Visits:970
Situated on 15+ surprisingly private acres, The Hermitage is a one-of-a-kind property. Originally built in 1925 with salvaged logs from two local barns, this historic home is a must-see property. Featured in Door County Living, Cabin Life, and showcased in House & Garden walks, this property has been in the same family since 1966.
$999,000Sold for 999,000.00 on 10/03/25
Lot 3 Gibraltar Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
12Picture(s)
3.50Acre
Visits:1792
Dreaming of owning your own property in Door County? Look no further than this highly desirable wooded parcel located just minutes and walking distance from Fish creek. Just a half mile east from the YMCA this to be created 3.
$229,900Sold for 230,000.00 on 01/06/26
Lot 2 Gibraltar Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
12Picture(s)
3.50Acre
Visits:1470
Dreaming of owning your own property in Door County? Look no further than this highly desirable wooded parcel located just minutes and walking distance from Fish creek. Just a half mile east from the YMCA this to be created 3.
$219,900Sold for 210,000.00 on 01/06/26
3771 Gibraltar Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
DetachedParking(s)
32Picture(s)
2,556Sqft
Visits:1219
Located just minutes from Fish Creek on the highly desirable Gibraltar Road and tucked back on 8.84 beautiful acres, this private retreat awaits! Featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a workshop, and outdoor inground pool, this private oasis offers the perfect year round residence, vacation getaway or investment property.
$749,900Sold for 739,900.00 on 11/03/25
Lot 1 Gibraltar Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
True North Real Estate LLC
12Picture(s)
3.50Acre
Visits:602
Dreaming of owning your own property in Door County? Look no further than this highly desirable wooded parcel located just minutes and walking distance from Fish creek. Just a half mile east from the YMCA this to be created 3.
$224,900Sold for 218,900.00 on 11/03/25
9173 Hidden Blossom Ln
Fish Creek, 54212
Kellstrom-Ray Agency
4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
GarageParking(s)
35Picture(s)
2,084Sqft
Visits:717
This exceptional end unit is a must see! It has gleaming Tigerwood flooring in the living areas, a vaulted ceiling with beams, stone fireplace and a wall of windows overlooking the pretty yard. Open concept with wonderful natural light with south and west exposures. Nice floor plan with first floor en suite. The 4th bedroom upstairs is being used as a den/office.
$549,000Sold for 555,000.00 on 10/31/25
3621 Juddville Rd
Fish Creek, 54212
CB Real Estate Group Egg Harbor
GravelParking(s)
11Picture(s)
5Acre
Visits:615
Discover the perfect blend of privacy and convenience with this beautiful 5-acre vacant lot, ideally located just minutes from both Fish Creek and Egg Harbor. Tucked away in a peaceful setting, this property offers a rare combination of open meadow and mature woods—ideal for those seeking tranquility, nature, and inspiring views.
$199,900Sold for 177,000.00 on 10/30/25