920.868.2828

Log In/Register

homes for sale in
fish creek / gibraltar

fish creek / gibraltar

The bayside village of Fish Creek is a lively, walkable town that includes some of Door County’s best known shops and restaurants, and borders Peninsula State Park. The town is also home to theaters, galleries and Door County’s largest performance venue, the Door Community Auditorium. Gibraltar Schools sit atop the Fish Creek hill, one of two public school systems that serve the children of Northern Door County.

  • Peninsula State Park is widely known as the Jewel of the Peninsula.
  • Find Fish Creek events, businesses and more information here.
  • The Door Community Auditorium features year round concerts, lectures and arts events.
  • Peninsula Players is America’s oldest resident summer theater, and its beautiful lakeside setting offers an unforgettable night out.
  • Peninsula School of Art offers year-round workshops, lectures, exhibits and family-friendly events for students of all ages and abilities.

    available listings

    Sort Option
      Grid
      List
      Map

      9177 Cottage Row Rd

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      Arbor Crowne Properties
      5Bedroom(s)
      4Bathroom(s)
      27Picture(s)
      3,172Sqft
      Visits:9
      Return to the early summers in Door County with a prestigious 1929 Cottage Row home and 264' of prime waterfront. This stunning Tudor Revival designed by Edwin Hill Clark and centered within an original Jens Jenson landscaping, this home was ahead of its time in design and amenities. Walk into history through hand carved arched doorways anchored with limestone and stucco.
      $4,987,000

      9246 Spring Rd

      Town of Gibraltar, WI 54212

      Keller Williams
      3Bedroom(s)
      2Bathroom(s)
      63Picture(s)
      2,353Sqft
      Visits:5
      Welcome to your dream home! This 3-bedroom, 2 and half bath beauty offers endless possibilities with a partially finished basement and potential for customization. It features a gas fireplace, hickory flooring, and Anderson windows for a touch of elegance. The sunroom offers captivating views of wildlife.
      $649,000

      Lot 21 Wildflower Patch Rd

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      Harbour Real Estate Group LLC
      5Picture(s)
      1.75Acre
      Visits:8
      Build your house on a bluff with a westerly sunset view overlooking Green Bay. This lot is perched above a Land Trust property so your view of Chambers Island, Hat Island and the lights of Marinette/Menominee will never be blocked. The property is located between Fish Creek and Egg Harbor. The site and view have been cleared and is ready for you to build your bluff view home.
      $399,999

      4184 Peninsula Players Rd

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      Kellstrom-Ray Agency
      4Bedroom(s)
      2Bathroom(s)
      45Picture(s)
      2,108Sqft
      Visits:31
      Nestled amidst rolling Fish Creek countryside and owned by the same family for over 6 decades, this 1900s farmhouse exudes timeless charm and character. It offers a glimpse into the past with original features, awaiting your personal touch to restore it to its former glory.
      $475,000

      4075 Hwy 42

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      Harbour Real Estate Group LLC
      11-25 SpacesParking(s)
      23Picture(s)
      4,196Sqft
      Visits:16
      Here is an exciting opportunity to purchase one of Door County's longest established and well-known retail stores located in beautiful downtown Fish Creek. Since 1997, Hat Head has been the premiere one-stop shop for headwear and accessories. They also feature in-store custom embroidery and have a well-established list of local, wholesale clients.
      $1,575,000

      8940 Gibraltar Bluff Rd

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      CB Real Estate Group Egg Harbor
      3Bedroom(s)
      2Bathroom(s)
      38Picture(s)
      3,192Sqft
      Visits:19
      A meandering drive through this 2+ acre wooded setting takes you to this lovely retreat. Conveniently located just south of Fish Creek, set among mature trees & in an area of fine homes, this 3+/2.5 was custom built by Tielens in 2002 & offers all the fine architectural elements of good craftsmanship.
      $879,000

      4176 Bluff Cr

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      Professional Realty of Door County
      4Bedroom(s)
      4Bathroom(s)
      52Picture(s)
      4,680Sqft
      Visits:46
      Tucked in the woods with breathtaking views of Fish Creek, Peninsula State Park and beyond. This custom-built home features an open living room with wood- burning fireplace, warm hardwood floors and vaulted ceiling. The home also offers 4+ bedrooms, a spacious office with built-in bookshelves, a lower level family/game room and a 2+ stall attached garage.
      $1,499,000

      4411 Daisy Patch Rd

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      True North Real Estate LLC
      2Bedroom(s)
      2Bathroom(s)
      54Picture(s)
      2,041Sqft
      Visits:83
      It's like walking into new construction! This lightly lived in, custom built home is full of the extras you'd hope for in a new build: stunning custom cabinetry, oak floors, a massive floor to ceiling stone fireplace, Andersen Windows, and much more. The primary suite features a luxurious bath, with soaking tub, double vanities, walk in shower and a large walk in closet.
      $729,000

      9331 Spring Rd

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      CB Real Estate Group Egg Harbor
      PavedParking(s)
      24Picture(s)
      1,147Sqft
      Visits:39
      Located within the bustling Top of the Hill Shops, this commercial space offers an ideal setting for your Door County business or professional practice. Boasting a spacious corner unit in impeccable condition, complete with expansive windows at both front and back, inviting ample natural light.
      $119,000Sold for $115,000 on 05/17/24

      3957 Main St

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      Realty Executives Cooper Spransy
      3Bedroom(s)
      2Bathroom(s)
      1 Car GarageParking(s)
      18Picture(s)
      1,910Sqft
      Visits:52
      Updated AND Convenient? Yes! Your next full-time or seasonal home is a hop, skip, or bike ride to Peninsula State Park, shopping, food, schools, and the Fish Creek Marina. The interior features an upgraded kitchen, hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings, tons of built-in storage, fireplace, gas stove and gasline for exterior grill. The newer AC, furnace, and hot water heater provide peace of mind.
      $550,000

      3745 Northhaven Dr

      Town of Gibraltar, WI 54212

      Abacus Realty Inc
      3Bedroom(s)
      2Bathroom(s)
      25Picture(s)
      2,422Sqft
      Visits:49
      Don't Miss Out on This ONE-OF-A-KIND, Custom Built, Deluxe, Upper End Condo Unit at Northhaven Condos.
      $649,900

      9351 Field Stone Ct

      Fish Creek, WI 54212

      Shorewest Realtors-Door County
      2Bedroom(s)
      1Bathroom(s)
      Assigned ParkingParking(s)
      23Picture(s)
      860Sqft
      Visits:42
      Rare opportunity to attain a lower unit at FCC great location and within footsteps of downtown Fish Creek. Peaceful wooded surroundings. Amenities include an in-ground pool and tennis courts. This unit includes a ductless AC/Heat unit. Seller is also including the dining room table w/4 chairs, 2 bar stools, and a cabinet next to the fireplace.The perfect getaway.
      $295,000
      63 Results returned.Per Page